Bad Side Of The Moon - Elton John Forum

Mega sondaggio canzoni: il progetto di Hercules

« Older   Newer »
  Share  
view post Posted on 22/2/2016, 21:47     +1   -1
Avatar

Advanced Member

Group:
Member
Posts:
8,098
Reputation:
+104
Location:
Siena

Status:


Ma in EJ siamo su livelli stellari, alcuni voti sono davvero ridicoli. Livelli grezzi, ma (forse proprio per questo) stellari!
 
Top
FPMalvone
view post Posted on 22/2/2016, 21:50     +1   -1




Beh, io qui lo dico, qui lo nego, non ho messo nessun voto inferiore al 9. :D
 
Top
view post Posted on 22/2/2016, 22:16     +1   -1
Avatar

Advanced Member

Group:
Member
Posts:
8,098
Reputation:
+104
Location:
Siena

Status:


Ho votato anche io. Praticamente, Louise e Cage sono le peggiori del disco. Mah.
 
Top
view post Posted on 29/2/2016, 12:35     +1   -1
Avatar

Advanced Member

Group:
Administrator
Posts:
5,735
Reputation:
+172

Status:


Questa settimana Tumbleweed!

Per ora non sta andando male, pensavo peggio: My Father's Gun se la gioca alla pari con England & America mentre Ballad of a Well Known Gun e Amoreena sono battuti solo di misura da Blue Wonderful e Looking Up.

Edited by deacon Lee - 29/2/2016, 13:02
 
Top
AlvinTostig
view post Posted on 29/2/2016, 15:32     +1   -1




Almeno in Tumbleweed nessun burlone si è divertito a votare zero :D
 
Top
FPMalvone
view post Posted on 29/2/2016, 15:50     +1   -1




Questi sono i più difficili da votare... la tentazione di dare 10 a tutte è forte...
...e poi ci si cede comunque :D
 
Top
madmanbb
view post Posted on 29/2/2016, 20:42     +1   -1




vado a votare!
 
Top
view post Posted on 18/3/2016, 10:03     +1   -1

eltoniano estremista

Group:
Member
Posts:
14,404
Reputation:
+7
Location:
provincia di firenze

Status:


CITAZIONE
Questa settimana Tumbleweed!

Si puo' votare ancora ??

CITAZIONE
mentre Ballad of a Well Known Gun e Amoreena sono battuti solo di misura da Blue Wonderful e Looking Up.

Ma lo stavi scrivendo ironicamente per ravvivare gli animi ??? :)
 
Top
ruicosta2003
view post Posted on 19/3/2016, 10:27     +1   -1




CITAZIONE (Jack_pinball @ 22/2/2016, 22:16) 
Ho votato anche io. Praticamente, Louise e Cage sono le peggiori del disco. Mah.

davvero... ma che strano..
 
Top
madmanbb
view post Posted on 19/3/2016, 10:36     -1   +1   -1




meglio non commentare certi risultati dei vari sondaggi, Elton ha i fans che si merita dopo le ennesime esecuzioni live di certe schifezze
 
Top
BiteUrLip
view post Posted on 23/3/2016, 15:46     +1   -1




Hi all dear Italian fans - I am the one behind the original idea and thought about to share a list of the first results and tell something more interesting about this project!

As you might have noticed, you are not able to see more answers than 100 first ones, but the good thing is, all survey answers will be saved (even past that one hundred!), and what I and Stephan of eltonfan.net are going to do is to wait until we've had all surveys open for enough long time so that all potential answers have appeared, and then buy a feature from SurveyMonkey for one month and then we will be able to reveal the complete results (all answers that have appeared will be then counted in). So, don't be afraid of the limit, answer as many surveys as you can and want, your votes will be counted in the end!

Before we get to that point, many months will pass and I thought it would be nice to sum up some results. So, I have two lists for you, and also the average scores for the albums. I decided not to mix the results of the first week with the results of the weeks 7, 8 and 9 because I believe that Wonderful Crazy Night received more favorable ratings because it is the newest album (for instance, wouldn't it be quite strange if "England And America" was higher in the list than "My Father's Gun"!).

Oh and one more thing - we recognized that someone has managed to answer multiple times from two different IP addresses, making the results look false. It is an absolute rule that only one survey answer is allowed per person. Thankfully it hasn't been problematic to remove those cheat answers manually. And hopefully the cheater will understand that the tryout to manipulate the average scores towards the person's own taste won't work - the cheat answers will get deleted sooner or later.

Anyway, in the future when forthcoming albums get 100 answers I will bring the results for you! I won't try to write the complete list as a message, so you'll just see the results of those albums previously not shown. I'm planning to reveal the results for Friends, 17-11-70, Madman and Honky Chateau as soon as the number of answers reach that number (and the cheat answers have been deleted...) next. And in addition to that, I will post a link to a file where you can see the complete results so far (all albums included with the exception of Wonderful Crazy Night).

The results of the introduction week:

England And America 8,17
The Open Chord 7,92
Blue Wonderful 7,84
Looking Up 7,83
A Good Heart 7,73
Wonderful Crazy Night 7,71
Guilty Pleasure 7,44
In The Name Of You 7,31
Claw Hammer 7,28
Free And Easy 7,27
I've Got 2 Wings 7,26
Tambourine 7,11
Children's Song 6,58
No Monsters 6,55

Average score: 7,54

The results of the surveys week 7, 8 and 9:

Your Song 9,49
Sixty Years On 9,11
Burn Down The Mission 8,99
The Greatest Discovery 8,85
Where To Now St. Peter? 8,62
Come Down In Time 8,54
Border Song 8,53
Skyline Pigeon 8,40
Take Me To The Pilot 8,31
The King Must Die 8,19
Talking Old Soldiers 8,17
Country Comfort 8,16
Amoreena 8,04
My Father's Gun 7,96
Bad Side Of The Moon 7,95
Into The Old Man's Shoes 7,80
The Ballad Of A Well-Known Gun 7,78
Madman Across The Water 7,72
Grey Seal [Original Version] 7,59
Love Song 7,55
Son Of Your Father 7,52
Rock And Roll Madonna 7,48
Lady Samantha 7,55
Empty Sky 7,50
The Cage 7,20
First Episode At Hienton 7,20
It's Me That You Need 7,19
No Shoe Strings On Louise 6,80
Just Like Strange Rain 6,50
Gulliver 6,39
All Across The Havens 6,26
I'm Going Home 6,26
Val-Hala 6,26
Sisters Of The Cross 6,22
Western Ford Gateway 6,20
All The Way Down To El Paso 6,19
Thank You Mama 6,11
Sails 6,02
Hymn 2000 5,53
The Scaffold 5,30
Hay-Chewed 5,18
Reprise 4,70

Average album scores:

Elton John 8,22
Tumbleweed Connection 8,13
Empty Sky 6,16

I want to thank all members of the Italian Elton fan community of your survey answers! You rock! :B):
 
Top
ruicosta2003
view post Posted on 30/3/2016, 07:04     +1   -1




ma il link con i risultati dove sarebbe...?

e non capisco come mai i risultti non sono aggiornti dopo i primi cento .. boh..?!
 
Top
lucaze
view post Posted on 30/3/2016, 10:54     +1   -1




Ricordo che io e Stephan avevamo già fatto qualcosa di molto simile in collaborazione con PolyGram Italia, mi sembra a fine anni 80 in un periodo di stanca dopo la release di Sleeping With The Past quando web e social erano nei sogni di pochi eletti e si usava ancora busta e penna (e, come direbbe Max, quando ero ancora fan del nostro :-)).
Anche in quel caso vennero fuori risultati piuttosto agghiaccianti... purtroppo i gusti dei fan tedeschi ho sempre faticato a capirli.
La prima volta che capito a casa dei miei recupero le riviste e copio ed incollo (ops, scansiono) i risultati.
 
Top
BiteUrLip
view post Posted on 4/4/2016, 03:38     +1   -1




Here are more results (weeks 10, 11, 12 and 13):

1. Rocket Man (I Think It's Going To Be A Long, Long Time) 9,40
2. Mona Lisas And Mad Hatters 9,25
3. Levon 9,14
4. Tiny Dancer 9,00
5. Indian Sunset 8,79
6. Sixty Years On [Live from 11-17-70] 8,70
7. Madman Across The Water 8,68
8. Burn Down The Mission [Live from 11-17-70] 8,58
9. Holiday Inn 8,44
10-11. Hercules 8,30
Friends 8,30
12. Honky Cat 8,03
13-14. Bad Side Of The Moon [Live from 11-17-70] 7,99
Can I Put You On [Live from 11-17-70] 7,99
15. Take Me To The Pilot [Live from 11-17-70] 7,97
16. Goodbye 7,88
17. I Think I'm Going To Kill Myself 7,83
18. Salvation 7,71
19. Can I Put You On 7,53
20. Honky Tonk Women [Live from 11-17-70] 7,51
21. Rotten Peaches 7,48
22. Amoreena [Live from 11-17-70] 7,47
22. Razor Face 7,44
23. Michelle's Song 7,31
24. Mellow 7,29
25. Get Back [Live from 17-11-70] 7,24
26. All The Nasties 7,22
27. My Baby Left Me [Live from 11-17-70] 7,18
28. Amy 7,08
29. Honey Roll 7,07
30. Slave 6,75
31. Susie (Dramas) 6,67
32-33. Seasons Reprise 6,23
Slave [Alternate Take] 6,23
34. Theme (The First Kiss)/Seasons 5,77
35. Variation On "Friends" 5,50
36. Variations on Michelle's Song (A Day in the Country) 5,43
37. Four Moods 5,04
38. I Meant to Do My Work Today (After All a Day in the Country) 4,81

Albums:

1. Madman Across The Water 8,24
2. 11-17-70 7,88
3. Honky Chateau 7,83
4. Friends 6,3

Coming up after these...: Don't Shoot Me, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (with Live at Hammersmith 1973 live album from the super deluxe edition) and Caribou. The further the project goes, the more lists and statistics I'm going to make as well.

We also might upgrade the account, because there is a limit which doesn't allow to delete more than 50 answers (no, the cheater still hasn't stopped to answer multiple times to the surveys...). It's going to be expensive if we upgrade it for one year, but the benefits could be worth it. The amount of survey answers in the near future will be decisive.

Edited by BiteUrLip - 4/4/2016, 06:30
 
Top
view post Posted on 4/4/2016, 08:47     -1   +1   -1
Avatar

Advanced Member

Group:
Administrator
Posts:
5,735
Reputation:
+172

Status:


Seasons 5,77 ????
Nella top 5 delle peggiori canzoni?
 
Top
31 replies since 15/2/2016, 18:01   534 views
  Share